Subtitled or Dubbed?

I finished the essay I was working on that refutes whether subtitled or dubbed anime is better for my Rhetoric and Writing class. If anyone wants to read it, email me, and I'll post it. Well here's a snipet from http://www.student.uwa.edu.au/student/predator/subvsdub.html that speaks on befalf of subtitled:
 

The Best Way to Watch Anime is...

SUBTITLED!
Why?!? Well here are the reasons:
1.  The subtitled versions are completely uncut!  While the
    english dubbed versions may be missing scenes that the
    dubbing companies don't feel are comfortable for mainstream
    audiences.
2.  The subtitled versions always have the entire original
    music, while the dubbed versions sometimes replace the
    original music with much worse "new" music.
3.  The subtitled versions feature the voices of professional
    anime voice-actors who are chosen after dozens of auditions.
    The dubbed versions feature the pathetic voices of whoever
    the dubbing companies can get to do the voices for the
    cheapest price; this results in totally unconvincing "acting"
    for the english dubbed version, which can often completely
    ruin the anime.
4.  The subtitled versions feature the most accurate english
    translations of the original script.  The dubbing companies
    usually change the parts of the script in the dubbed version
    which they think audiences may be too unintelligent to
    understand (pretty insulting isn't it?).
So basically, if you want to see Japanese Animation the way the creators intended you to see it (rather than a simplified, inferior dubbed version) then SUBTITLED versions are the only way to go!

(Back to Anime Table of Contents)

Back To D.J.'s Homepage